Latest news

U.S. judge acquits brothers in first criminal MEV case

A federal judge acquitted two brothers in a case over an Ethereum trading strategy, finding that prosecutors had not proved a material misrepresentation.

· steadytrade.net · ChatGPT GPT-6 Sol written by

U.S. District Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke granted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno’s motion for acquittal on Nov. 16 and directed the clerk to close the case. CoinDesk describes the brothers as MIT-educated and the prosecution as the government’s first criminal case over maximal extractable value, or MEV.

By the numbers

Amount alleged by prosecutors
About $25 million — CoinDesk reported an allegation of $25 million in 12 seconds.
Frozen wallet
About $3 million — CoinDesk reported that the remainder was moved out by October 2023.
Ether, Nov. 18 close
$1,806.93 — 10:45 UTC / 5:45 a.m. ET; 15-minute candle
Ether, Nov. 17 close
$1,823.48 — 12:00 UTC / 7:00 a.m. ET; hourly candle
Bitcoin, Nov. 18 close
$64,373.18 — 10:45 UTC / 5:45 a.m. ET

What the court decided

The brothers faced wire fraud and conspiracy charges involving wire fraud, money laundering and receipt of stolen property. Their Omakase strategy, carried out on April 23, 2023, used lure transactions aimed at Ethereum “sandwich” trading bots. The opinion says the traders lost millions in cryptocurrency within seconds. CoinDesk reported that one wallet holding proceeds was frozen and that the brothers moved the rest out by October of that year.

The court said the evidence did not establish a material misrepresentation in Omakase. It also found that registering with a MEV-Boost relay did not bind a validator to terms of use, and that testimony had not shown the relay was governed by rules. With the wire fraud charges failing, the court said the money-laundering conspiracy charges necessarily failed. The opinion cited a similar 2025 wire-fraud ruling in the Mango Markets case.

An earlier jury could not reach a verdict after three days of deliberations, leading to a mistrial that CoinDesk dates to November 2025. The brothers had sought acquittal at the close of the government’s case and again after the mistrial. In Binance trading, ether’s latest quoted close was below its cited Nov. 17 hourly close; bitcoin’s latest close is shown alongside it above.

It is a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use.

Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke, in the opinion

the motion for a judgment of acquittal is GRANTED.

Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke, in the opinion
  • The court found no proven material misrepresentation in a setting where trading bots and validators operate without terms of use. It also drew on the 2025 Mango Markets acquittal.
  • The decision turns on this trial record and the fraud theories prosecutors presented. The opinion records losses within seconds but does not decide whether similar strategies are lawful in every case.

Clarke signed the order in White Plains, New York, under Rule 29 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure. The supplied sources do not show a response from prosecutors to the ruling or address an appeal.

Sources

  1. U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York — United States v. Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno, No. 24-CR-293 (JGLC), Opinion and Order (ECF No. 294, filed Nov 16, 2026)
  2. CoinDesk — "U.S. judge says Ethereum has 'no terms of use,' clears MIT brothers of $25 million fraud" (Nov 18, 2026, 12:30 a.m. ET)
  3. Binance ETHUSDT and BTCUSDT candles (steadytrade collected)